Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2019

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2019

Author: Axel Calissendorff

Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Published: 2019-08-14

Total Pages: 327

ISBN-13: 9403506830

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This new annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. This first issue provides authoritative articles, some of them with a Swedish angle, that address current matters of global concern in arbitration, including the following: multi-appointment bias; cross-examination and advocacy in arbitration; due process – paranoia or prudence?; robots as arbitrators; security for costs and third-party funding in investment arbitration; and the ‘Arbitration Station’ podcast. Recent developments in Swedish arbitration-related case law are summarized. The 2019 changes in the Swedish Arbitration Act are presented. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel, and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also prove valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies, and arbitral institutions worldwide.


Book Synopsis Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2019 by : Axel Calissendorff

Download or read book Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2019 written by Axel Calissendorff and published by Kluwer Law International B.V.. This book was released on 2019-08-14 with total page 327 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This new annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. This first issue provides authoritative articles, some of them with a Swedish angle, that address current matters of global concern in arbitration, including the following: multi-appointment bias; cross-examination and advocacy in arbitration; due process – paranoia or prudence?; robots as arbitrators; security for costs and third-party funding in investment arbitration; and the ‘Arbitration Station’ podcast. Recent developments in Swedish arbitration-related case law are summarized. The 2019 changes in the Swedish Arbitration Act are presented. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel, and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also prove valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies, and arbitral institutions worldwide.

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2020

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2020

Author: Axel Calissendorff

Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Published: 2020-11-27

Total Pages: 401

ISBN-13: 9403524111

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition provides authoritative chapters, some of them with a Swedish angle, that address current matters of global concern in arbitration, including the following: dispute resolution in the financial sector; emergency arbitration; recent Swedish case law related to arbitration and in particular one seminal case; arbitrator liability; the right to a public hearing in arbitration; and squeeze-out arbitration. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel, and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies, and arbitral institutions worldwide.


Book Synopsis Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2020 by : Axel Calissendorff

Download or read book Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2020 written by Axel Calissendorff and published by Kluwer Law International B.V.. This book was released on 2020-11-27 with total page 401 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition provides authoritative chapters, some of them with a Swedish angle, that address current matters of global concern in arbitration, including the following: dispute resolution in the financial sector; emergency arbitration; recent Swedish case law related to arbitration and in particular one seminal case; arbitrator liability; the right to a public hearing in arbitration; and squeeze-out arbitration. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel, and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies, and arbitral institutions worldwide.

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2023

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2023

Author: Patrik Scholdstrom

Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Published: 2024-01-16

Total Pages: 540

ISBN-13: 9403503688

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition’s topics include: arbitration and EU sanctions against Russia; the ins and outs of arbitrator selection; the divide between lawful and unlawful expropriation in investment arbitration; tactical misuse of GDPR in arbitration; court-assisted preservation of evidence; and the distinction between jurisdiction and admissibility. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies and arbitral institutions worldwide.


Book Synopsis Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2023 by : Patrik Scholdstrom

Download or read book Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2023 written by Patrik Scholdstrom and published by Kluwer Law International B.V.. This book was released on 2024-01-16 with total page 540 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition’s topics include: arbitration and EU sanctions against Russia; the ins and outs of arbitrator selection; the divide between lawful and unlawful expropriation in investment arbitration; tactical misuse of GDPR in arbitration; court-assisted preservation of evidence; and the distinction between jurisdiction and admissibility. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies and arbitral institutions worldwide.

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2021

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2021

Author: Axel Calissendorff

Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Published: 2021-10-08

Total Pages: 468

ISBN-13: 940353530X

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook Series, VOLUME 3 Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition’s topics include: a guide to the arbitral tribunal’s deliberation and decision-making; getting unwilling witnesses to appear; recent Swedish case law related to arbitration; claims based on fraud and other non-contractual claims; two parties with several arbitration agreements; and interaction between experts and the arbitral tribunal. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies and arbitral institutions worldwide.


Book Synopsis Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2021 by : Axel Calissendorff

Download or read book Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2021 written by Axel Calissendorff and published by Kluwer Law International B.V.. This book was released on 2021-10-08 with total page 468 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook Series, VOLUME 3 Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty. This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition’s topics include: a guide to the arbitral tribunal’s deliberation and decision-making; getting unwilling witnesses to appear; recent Swedish case law related to arbitration; claims based on fraud and other non-contractual claims; two parties with several arbitration agreements; and interaction between experts and the arbitral tribunal. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies and arbitral institutions worldwide.

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2022

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2022

Author: Axel Calissendorff

Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Published: 2023-01-10

Total Pages: 426

ISBN-13: 9403519665

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2022, Volume 4 Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT). This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition’s topics include: the impact of EU law on dispute resolution in international investment and trade agreements; execution of arbitral award against sovereign wealth fund assets; recent Nordic case law related to post-M&A arbitration; expert decisions; corruption and arbitration; and investment protection under the ECT in relation to an underwater gas pipeline project. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies and arbitral institutions worldwide.


Book Synopsis Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2022 by : Axel Calissendorff

Download or read book Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2022 written by Axel Calissendorff and published by Kluwer Law International B.V.. This book was released on 2023-01-10 with total page 426 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Stockholm Arbitration Yearbook 2022, Volume 4 Each year, Stockholm is the arbitration seat of choice for numerous parties endeavouring to resolve international disputes. It is the second most used venue for investment disputes, and it is often the venue for disputes arising from the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT). This annual publication, launched under the auspices of the Stockholm Centre for Commercial Law, is designed to meet the information needs of arbitration practitioners and parties from all over the world. The present edition’s topics include: the impact of EU law on dispute resolution in international investment and trade agreements; execution of arbitral award against sovereign wealth fund assets; recent Nordic case law related to post-M&A arbitration; expert decisions; corruption and arbitration; and investment protection under the ECT in relation to an underwater gas pipeline project. The Yearbook provides both perspective and detailed analyses that will be welcomed by arbitration practitioners, counsel and judges deciding arbitration cases. It will also provide valuable insights for arbitration academics, in-house counsel at multinational companies and arbitral institutions worldwide.

International Arbitration in Sweden

International Arbitration in Sweden

Author: Annette Magnusson

Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Published: 2021-03-09

Total Pages: 557

ISBN-13: 9403525622

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

Sweden is one of a handful of countries where the international arbitral process has reached a stage where the jurisprudence is replete with instances involving no local parties at all. In this context of credible neutrality, the Arbitration Institute of the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce (SCC) has emerged as a leading global arbitral institution. Whether the matter at issue is a business transaction dispute or a politicized conflict involving obdurate parties, the richness of its body of decided cases manifests the SCC’s authority and reliability throughout the converging world of international arbitration. The present book, written by sixteen eminent practitioners and now in its second edition, provides a practical guide to international arbitration in Sweden, whether ad hoc or institutional. Among the many elements of practice and procedure detailed are the following: appointment, challenge, removal, and compensation of arbitrators; procedural efficiency and costs; use of international legal sources such as IBA guidelines; choice of law by parties; SCC rules and procedures; multiparty arbitrations – joinder, intervention, consolidation; investment treaty arbitration; confidentiality; documentary evidence, witnesses, and experts; grounds for setting aside; party succession; Swedish court review of the arbitrator’s jurisdiction; and appeal of arbitrators’ compensation. In addition, readers will be exposed to a trove of pertinent references to important decisions that have, in recent decades, been generated by the stream of major international arbitrations conducted in Sweden. Disputing parties wishing to know what will happen when their case is brought to Sweden for arbitration will find no clearer or more thorough guide. This book is an incomparable source for anyone called upon to act as arbitrator or counsel, or in any other capacity, in international arbitration in Sweden.


Book Synopsis International Arbitration in Sweden by : Annette Magnusson

Download or read book International Arbitration in Sweden written by Annette Magnusson and published by Kluwer Law International B.V.. This book was released on 2021-03-09 with total page 557 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Sweden is one of a handful of countries where the international arbitral process has reached a stage where the jurisprudence is replete with instances involving no local parties at all. In this context of credible neutrality, the Arbitration Institute of the Stockholm Chamber of Commerce (SCC) has emerged as a leading global arbitral institution. Whether the matter at issue is a business transaction dispute or a politicized conflict involving obdurate parties, the richness of its body of decided cases manifests the SCC’s authority and reliability throughout the converging world of international arbitration. The present book, written by sixteen eminent practitioners and now in its second edition, provides a practical guide to international arbitration in Sweden, whether ad hoc or institutional. Among the many elements of practice and procedure detailed are the following: appointment, challenge, removal, and compensation of arbitrators; procedural efficiency and costs; use of international legal sources such as IBA guidelines; choice of law by parties; SCC rules and procedures; multiparty arbitrations – joinder, intervention, consolidation; investment treaty arbitration; confidentiality; documentary evidence, witnesses, and experts; grounds for setting aside; party succession; Swedish court review of the arbitrator’s jurisdiction; and appeal of arbitrators’ compensation. In addition, readers will be exposed to a trove of pertinent references to important decisions that have, in recent decades, been generated by the stream of major international arbitrations conducted in Sweden. Disputing parties wishing to know what will happen when their case is brought to Sweden for arbitration will find no clearer or more thorough guide. This book is an incomparable source for anyone called upon to act as arbitrator or counsel, or in any other capacity, in international arbitration in Sweden.

Construction Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution

Construction Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution

Author: Renato Nazzini

Publisher: Taylor & Francis

Published: 2021-10-21

Total Pages: 471

ISBN-13: 100044869X

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

This book provides comprehensive, rigorous and up-to-date coverage of key issues that have emerged in the first quarter of the 21st Century in transnational construction arbitration and alternative dispute resolution (ADR). Covering four general themes, this book discusses: the increasing internationalisation of dispute resolution in construction law; the increasing reliance on technology in the management of construction projects and construction arbitration/ADR; the increasing prominence of collaborative contracting in construction and infrastructure projects; the increasing importance of contractual adjudication such as dispute boards in construction and infrastructure projects; the increasing prevalence of statutory adjudication mechanisms across the world; and the greater incidence of investment disputes and disputes against States and State entities over construction and infrastructure concessions and agreements. Tapping on their substantial expertise in practice and in research, the contributor team of senior practitioners and academics in the area of construction law and dispute resolution provide readers with information that balances an intellectually rigorous academic contribution against the backdrop of real concerns raised in practice. Construction Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution is an invaluable resource for practitioners in the field, academics in arbitration and construction law, and post-graduate students in construction law and dispute resolution.


Book Synopsis Construction Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution by : Renato Nazzini

Download or read book Construction Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution written by Renato Nazzini and published by Taylor & Francis. This book was released on 2021-10-21 with total page 471 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: This book provides comprehensive, rigorous and up-to-date coverage of key issues that have emerged in the first quarter of the 21st Century in transnational construction arbitration and alternative dispute resolution (ADR). Covering four general themes, this book discusses: the increasing internationalisation of dispute resolution in construction law; the increasing reliance on technology in the management of construction projects and construction arbitration/ADR; the increasing prominence of collaborative contracting in construction and infrastructure projects; the increasing importance of contractual adjudication such as dispute boards in construction and infrastructure projects; the increasing prevalence of statutory adjudication mechanisms across the world; and the greater incidence of investment disputes and disputes against States and State entities over construction and infrastructure concessions and agreements. Tapping on their substantial expertise in practice and in research, the contributor team of senior practitioners and academics in the area of construction law and dispute resolution provide readers with information that balances an intellectually rigorous academic contribution against the backdrop of real concerns raised in practice. Construction Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution is an invaluable resource for practitioners in the field, academics in arbitration and construction law, and post-graduate students in construction law and dispute resolution.

International Arbitration in England

International Arbitration in England

Author: Laila Hamzi

Publisher: Kluwer Law International B.V.

Published: 2022-08-09

Total Pages: 602

ISBN-13: 9403522259

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

There is no question that in recent years, the case law, practice and legal environment in which international arbitration in England is practised have all evolved and adapted to a changing world and continue to do so. In this book, a diverse range of practitioners chart this development with detailed consideration of the challenges and opportunities for the future of international arbitration in England. The topics chosen often reflect and explore preoccupations of our times, including such aspects of arbitral practice as the following: challenges to arbitrators, with particular attention to the Supreme Court’s findings in Halliburton v. Chubb; virtual hearings; diversity in international arbitration; climate change arbitration; ‘green arbitration’ practices; developing jurisprudence regarding enjoining foreign states in English proceedings; recovery of in-house costs in English-seated international arbitrations; overlapping sanctions regimes and their application to arbitral disputes in England; and the role and future of third-party funding. The fact that the essays were all written during the COVID-19 pandemic is reflected in the procedural issues which form the focus of some chapters, reminding us that when it comes, change can come quickly. For this reason, the deeply informed insights in this volume, intended as they are to ensure the continued evolution and success of international arbitration in England, will prove of immeasurable value for any practitioner making submissions before an arbitral tribunal. Jurists, academics and students will gain invaluable perspectives on the future trajectory of the field.


Book Synopsis International Arbitration in England by : Laila Hamzi

Download or read book International Arbitration in England written by Laila Hamzi and published by Kluwer Law International B.V.. This book was released on 2022-08-09 with total page 602 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: There is no question that in recent years, the case law, practice and legal environment in which international arbitration in England is practised have all evolved and adapted to a changing world and continue to do so. In this book, a diverse range of practitioners chart this development with detailed consideration of the challenges and opportunities for the future of international arbitration in England. The topics chosen often reflect and explore preoccupations of our times, including such aspects of arbitral practice as the following: challenges to arbitrators, with particular attention to the Supreme Court’s findings in Halliburton v. Chubb; virtual hearings; diversity in international arbitration; climate change arbitration; ‘green arbitration’ practices; developing jurisprudence regarding enjoining foreign states in English proceedings; recovery of in-house costs in English-seated international arbitrations; overlapping sanctions regimes and their application to arbitral disputes in England; and the role and future of third-party funding. The fact that the essays were all written during the COVID-19 pandemic is reflected in the procedural issues which form the focus of some chapters, reminding us that when it comes, change can come quickly. For this reason, the deeply informed insights in this volume, intended as they are to ensure the continued evolution and success of international arbitration in England, will prove of immeasurable value for any practitioner making submissions before an arbitral tribunal. Jurists, academics and students will gain invaluable perspectives on the future trajectory of the field.

Expedited Procedures in International Commercial Arbitration

Expedited Procedures in International Commercial Arbitration

Author: Andreas Wehowsky

Publisher: sui generis Verlag

Published: 2023-07-24

Total Pages: 358

ISBN-13: 3907297423

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

International arbitration has enjoyed remarkable success. However, in recent years repeated concerns relating to the efficiency of the proceedings have emerged. These concerns have led to the introduction of provisions for expedited arbitral procedures. Through analysing various arbitration rules, this book will examine the require-ments under which expedited procedures are admissible, what the central char-acteristics of such procedures are, and how such procedures can be classified and described in comparison to a conventional arbitral procedure. A significant part will examine the tension between procedural efficiency on the one hand and on quality of the procedure and award on the other. In an excursus, early determination procedures will be examined to complete the tool box to increase procedural efficiency.


Book Synopsis Expedited Procedures in International Commercial Arbitration by : Andreas Wehowsky

Download or read book Expedited Procedures in International Commercial Arbitration written by Andreas Wehowsky and published by sui generis Verlag. This book was released on 2023-07-24 with total page 358 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: International arbitration has enjoyed remarkable success. However, in recent years repeated concerns relating to the efficiency of the proceedings have emerged. These concerns have led to the introduction of provisions for expedited arbitral procedures. Through analysing various arbitration rules, this book will examine the require-ments under which expedited procedures are admissible, what the central char-acteristics of such procedures are, and how such procedures can be classified and described in comparison to a conventional arbitral procedure. A significant part will examine the tension between procedural efficiency on the one hand and on quality of the procedure and award on the other. In an excursus, early determination procedures will be examined to complete the tool box to increase procedural efficiency.

The Regulation of International Commercial Arbitration

The Regulation of International Commercial Arbitration

Author: João Ilhão Moreira

Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing

Published: 2024-07-25

Total Pages: 433

ISBN-13: 1509962700

DOWNLOAD EBOOK

This book addresses how the regulation of international commercial arbitrators takes place. International commercial arbitrators are a unique category of service providers because they are not organised as other professionals such as accountants, lawyers and doctors. The book provides an overview of how and why the regulation of international commercial arbitrators diverged from that of other professions. It also argues that, despite these differences, there is an effective regulatory environment overseeing the behaviour of international commercial arbitrators. The book unpicks the different elements that contribute to the creation and enforcement of professional norms in this field. It explains how the specific characteristics of the arbitral market create strong incentives for ethical norms to be created, even in the absence of the institutions that usually address these issues in other fields. It also describes how market and social forces drive arbitrators to comply with these norms in most circumstances. Finally, the book addresses the ways in which this regulatory system also explains some of the perceived weaknesses of arbitration, namely the rising costs of proceedings and the perceived unfairness of appointments.


Book Synopsis The Regulation of International Commercial Arbitration by : João Ilhão Moreira

Download or read book The Regulation of International Commercial Arbitration written by João Ilhão Moreira and published by Bloomsbury Publishing. This book was released on 2024-07-25 with total page 433 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: This book addresses how the regulation of international commercial arbitrators takes place. International commercial arbitrators are a unique category of service providers because they are not organised as other professionals such as accountants, lawyers and doctors. The book provides an overview of how and why the regulation of international commercial arbitrators diverged from that of other professions. It also argues that, despite these differences, there is an effective regulatory environment overseeing the behaviour of international commercial arbitrators. The book unpicks the different elements that contribute to the creation and enforcement of professional norms in this field. It explains how the specific characteristics of the arbitral market create strong incentives for ethical norms to be created, even in the absence of the institutions that usually address these issues in other fields. It also describes how market and social forces drive arbitrators to comply with these norms in most circumstances. Finally, the book addresses the ways in which this regulatory system also explains some of the perceived weaknesses of arbitration, namely the rising costs of proceedings and the perceived unfairness of appointments.